Ok, I went and found my old card sleeves that I had back from my MTG, GOT, and other CCGs. I had almost enough to cover all the cards I have so far. The problem is now that I have the cards in sleeves, they no longer fit in the awesome cool box. So, how does everyone keep their cards protected and store them?
That actually depends on which printing of the EE you have. I've been told that newer versions of the EE have/will have the cards cut to the correct height.
I was referring more to the fact that regular Mayday sleeves aren't always consistent length-wise, but there is also a minor difference in card height. They seem to fit Infernal Relics and Promo cards best, followed by Rook City, and fit worst in the EE. I had the same issue JH is having when I sleeved my cards in penny sleeves. I much prefer having my cards fit in the box with slightly-too-small sleeves rather than my box not closing all the way.
The Container Store has a clear card case (http://www.containerstore.com/shop/toyStorage/boxesCases?productId=10003484&N=80471) that works for the cards with sleeves with one problem. If you put the cool separators from the EE box then the lid doesn't fit. But I think I might go with this and not use the lid.
It would be cool, as I have seen mentioned, if GTG came out with both SotM card sleeves and a box that will fit EVERYTHING. Might be something they do in the future. :)
BTW, keep any suggestions you have coming as what I am presently doing is not optimal at all.
The EE box will hold every card, including Promo decks and Character cards, up to Infernal Relics in Mayday sleeves. It will not fit tokens if the cards are sleeved, however. I dunno if I really want Sentinels card sleeves, as I like the unique backs to each deck (and making sleeves for each hero deck would be a bit of a ripoff, in my opinion). Shattered Timelines should be able to fit into Vengeance (when they are released) just fine, so that's when you may want to invest in a bigger box if you want everything to fit in one container. It sounds like you've found an interesting alternative to the EE box, but I would highly recommend using the Mayday sleeves. The Sentinels box is a really nice piece to show off to new players, and the tokens can easily be stored in a dice bag.
I use exclusively KMC Perfect Size sleeves for everything, and the entirety of Sentinels fits in the EE box with all of the promos and additional swag from the Kickstarters. The box doesn't quite close because I have all 3 rulebooks (EE, RC, and IE) and the oversized villain cards on top of everything. That being said, it all fits.
The cheap Ultra-Pro sleeves kind of fit in the box (they all went in, but they bowed out the side), and then as someone suggested I cut out the side inner lining of the box, and now they do fit perfectly in the box. That's with all the expansions and promo cards, and Unity and Ambuscade. Put them in with the top of the cards facing the inside divider and they might all fit without having to cut up the box. The tops will be squeezed, but it's not a big deal.
That sounds great. I don't think I'm willing to invest in another 1200 sleeves in order to switch, but if I was buying now, this is probably what I'd go with.