Welcome! 
This sounds cool!
In case you hadn’t seen them and are interested, the second premium token pack includes tokens that are identical to the original defense tokens (image below). 
But if you want to make your own, I definitely understand. 
Unfortunately, I have no idea what wood they’re made of. 
You might be able to email contact@greaterthangames.com and see if they can help you?
I’m honestly not sure if it’ll be discernable once they’re painted, though. 
(Not saying that it is or isn’t – I honestly just don’t know. 
)
