Question of the Day!

See Deadline in SotM

2 Likes

Yes and then Lifeline is an antihero. Tarogath just can’t do the traditional hero/villain formula ā€œrightā€ from either side.

1 Like

Thanks for clearing that up, everyone. I guess I was mostly confused because I was trying to ā€œmirrorā€ the Ant-Hero concept. The Anti-Hero does things a villainous way for heroic reasons, so I thought that an Anti-Villain must do things in heroic ways for villainous reasons, but that didn’t quite make much sense.

So, I suppose that the Anti-Villain also does things in villainous ways for heroic reasons, but the only thing differentiating them from Anti-Heroes is that the good that comes from an Anti-Hero’s actions outweigh the amorality of those actions, whereas the Anti-Villain’s villainous actions’ ā€œgoodā€ outcomes don’t make up for those actions’ inherent evility.

Also, I’ve not read Watchmen, but from what I’ve heard, I think it sounds a bit too Deconstruction-y and ā€œmatureā€ for my tastes.

Question of the Day #184: The Man of Tomorrow, The Caped Crusader, or The Webslinger?

That’s a distinctly limited slate to choose from (the absolute two biggest DC heroes, versus only one from Marvel, and debatably not even their best known). But of those three, I pick The Man Of Tomorrow by a landslide. Especially if he’s written by someone who really understands the character. Probably my single favorite portrayal is in the Birthright graphic novel, which I believe is by Mark Waid. Plus there’s the semi-famous story where he finds a woman who’s about to jump off a building, and persuades her that there’s still hope and she shouldn’t give up on life, and gives her a hug. I don’t remember who did that story, but it’s probably the single best distillation of Superman as a character. (Clearly Zack Snyder has never read it.)

1 Like

I’d go with Spidey. He’s actually relatable, which I appreciate. (Also the reason I prefer Marvel to DC, in general.) I enjoy Supes when he’s well written as the heroic, positive character and Bats when he’s being a smart detective, but they just never held a candle to Spider-Man.

1 Like

Yeah, I just thought that ā€œWho’s your favourite superhero?ā€ is kinda a boring question, and it would be more interesting comparing (what I think are) the three most popular heroes.

Well, I just thought of it as ā€œthe three most popular heroes.ā€

Really? I certainly would say he is. I suppose that, because of the MCU, Iron Man may have recently caught up.

Yeah . . . The Man of Steel is the worst Hero to make all dark and gritty (other than America’s Finest Legacy, of course). I am not very impressed by Snyder’s rendition.

Here here!

QotD #184 Reply: As you may have realised by know, I don’t have favourites. Superman is The Superhero, Batman is The Badass Normal, and Spider-Man is The Everyman Hero.

Question of the Day #185: Who is your favourite Superhero? OR Who do you think is the most popular Superhero (for each company, or in general)?

My favorite shifts between Batman and Spider-Man mostly and Nightcrawler is one of my favorites as well. Spider-Man I know is the best selling character for Marvel, and most likely Batman for DC.

Ultimate extreme grimdark Dazzler would probably be worse. Or ā€œAmethyst, Princess of Gemworldā€. But yeah, Supes is definitely up there.

I think that he eventually got there. The Justice League movie is legitimately good imo, and BvS was okay mostly, although Supes was clearly the worst part of it. But the fact that they were doing the whole thing as a sequel to Man of Steel really held them back. General Zod was SO bad in that one, and Kevin Costner pretty much proved how over his career is. Marvel had little trouble abandoning the two Hulk movies and just starting the Avengers over with a different Hulk; DC should have pulled the plug on MoS likewise.

If they ever do another Supes movie, I hope they’ll title it ā€œMan of Tomorrowā€, and give us a character more akin to Samaritan from Busiek’s Astro City setting, who is clearly a Superman expy who comes from Earth’s future to try and ensure it happens. Instead of the weird organic technology thing Snyder did with Krypton, just make it an Earth-like planet, several thousand years ahead in technology, and have Kal-El show up with a mission to ensure Earth avoids the mistakes that eventually led to Krypton’s destruction.

I tend to be a bit on the obscure side with my tastes, not because I’m a hipster or anything, but just because I get tired very quickly of the more over-exposed heroes, and like seeing something different. (The fact that SOTM doesn’t push the Freedom Five too hard, and lets most of the other 25-odd heroes have at least a vaguely comparable degree of the spotlight, is a big piece of why I like SOTM so much, compared to several other superhero game franchises.)

My single favorite superhero of all is John Jones, the Manhunter from Mars; telepathy plus shapeshifting alone is godlike, and he can pretty much make Batman look like an amateur at the detective game, while also having Superman’s entire powerset, balanced by a weakness that’s far more likely to come up than ā€œmeteor rocksā€, as Smallville put it.

Other than that, my DC favorites are Wonder Woman, Green Lantern, Power Girl, Batman and Superman in pretty much that order, with an honorable mention for Shazam, mostly because of the excellent 2019 movie about him (this and the two Wonder Woman movies are the flipside of the Man of Steel problem). I also like some of the oddball offshoots of the main DCU, such as the Doom Patrol, John Constantine, the Metal Men, and above all the Neil Gaiman version of the Sandman. I’m probably forgetting a couple others who I also enjoy when they show up, members of the Justice Society or the Legion of Superheroes or something, but DC really likes to lean on their heavy hitters, without the degree of balance Marvel tries to have (in the comics at least; the whole sold-off-the-movie-rights debacle kinda forced the MCU to do things a little more DC-style).

Marvel-wise, I think Hulk is far and away the most uniquely important single character they have, the only one that isn’t very clearly outshone by DC’s pantheon. Spiderman is probably one of the runners-up, and the Fantastic Four as a unit also qualify, while being more to my preference even than Hulk (The Thing in particular is one of my favorite Marvel characters, with Johnny as runner up). I didn’t really care about Iron Man until the movie, and he’s still not one of my very favorites; I have more of a personal fondness for Doctor Strange, and I think Captain America beats Iron Man in both general popularity and my personal fondness. But above all others, except maybe Hulk, what I think Marvel gave the superhero world is not a single hero but a whole race of them, the X-Men. I go for ensemble pieces far more than for single hero stories, and the soap opera dynamics among Xavier’s merry mutants are endlessly fascinating to me. My favorites among the group are pretty definitely Storm, Professor X, and Gambit (especially when paired with Rogue, who is less interesting by herself). Again, my fondness for the more obscure characters comes up a lot here, with some of the really bizarre mutants like Maggot and Dust being particularly notable to me.

Among heroes who I think are popular but I don’t really care about them, I think the Arrow TV show has probably given Oliver Queen a huge boost, but aside from his buddy-cop period with the Green Lantern (who is clearly a far more powerful and larger scope hero, who is out of place operating on Green Arrow’s level, just as Batman has always seemed like an odd inclusion in the JLA), I really don’t particularly find him impressive. Black Canary interests me much more. Marvel likewise has a number of their characters bolstered by movies, with Deadpool topping the list of those I don’t like very much, and the various Captains and Miszess Marvels being the ones I don’t care about at all. Mar-Vell was barely interesting to me when he was Rick Jones, the former kid sidekick of the Hulk; Monica Rambeau was alright, but suffered an unfortunate costume overlap with DC villain turned rapist Doctor Light, so that may have been a factor in her sorta just fading away. But Carol Danvers? Complete snore-fest; I’m pretty sure the continuity I imprinted upon was the one in which Carol was calling herself Miss or Miz Marvel, and Mystique ordered a then-criminal Rogue to drain Carol to death, gaining her speed and flight powers permanently. This might only have been true in a cartoon or something, but it was the version I thought best, since Rogue was much more interesting than Carol. Now, for whatever reason, Carol is back and calling herself Captain, while the Miss Marvel name belongs to a ridiculous meme of an Inhuman named Kamala Khan, who I know almost nothing about, but basically everything I’ve heard is that she’s terribly written for the sole purpose of pandering to audiences that really weren’t interested in reading comics, up until the comics were changed to try and appeal to them. Maybe that’s a reductive way to put it, but the bottom line is that I’ve been given no reason to care about this character.

Oh boy, Blackest Night was my on ramp to comics, and I really fell in love with Barry Allen there, and as I got deeper I became a huge fan of Nightwing. Over on the Marvel side I’m a huge fan of Gwenpool. I’m currently in a spot with Sentinels where nothing else can hold a candle to these characters in my ADHD hyperfixation shrouded eyes though, and it’s just impossible for me to pic a real favorite out of that lineup, though if you held a gun to my head about it I’d say Tachyon

I wasn’t aware of those two until now, but yeah, they would be pretty bad too.

Yep, that might’ve improved the other movies considerably.

Yeah, I guess so. I didn’t like how the JLA was losing in the final battle with that wolf guy, but then Superman showed up and they easily won. Also, Aquaman was way too much of a tough guy, in my opinion, the portrayal of The Flash just seemed off somehow, and the Martian Manhunter (well, in the version I watched), Green Lantern, and Green Arrow were entirely absent. Anyway, that’s a topic that’s neither here nor there.

That sounds like a promising, interesting, and different plot!

It’s always good to hear that folks like what is probably(?) the least well-known member of the JLA. (I still don’t like that DC replaced him with Cyborg in some continuities . . . )

Wait, do you just like J’onn because he’s powerful?

Yeah, the Hulk’s good, if he’s written with the Hulk-Bruce Banner dichotomy-duality.

I can agree on that.

No, I think I vaguely recall that happening in a comic continuity.

QotD #185 Reply: Most Popular? Definitely Legacy. ; ) (What? I never said " . . . in this Universe.") Okay, fine. In our reality, like I said above, I think Superman, Batman, and Spider-Man were the most popular. In what order? I dunno. However, after the MCU, Stark may also be up there somewhere.

As for favourites, as I have said numerous times before, I don’t have one favourite. But, I’m still human, so of course I do like some Heroes more than others.

From DC, in the Justice League I like Superman, Batman, The Flash (Jay Garrick & Barry Allen), Green Lantern (Alan Scott & Hal Jordan), The Martian Manhunter, Aquaman, and Green Arrow, and some of their lesser known members, such as Zatanna and the Atom. I’m not very familiar with most of the JSA, but I do like Doctor Fate and Sandman (Wesley Dodds, not Gaiman’s Singular Entity of Sleep). I like the Legion of Super-Heroes, but I don’t really like any members more than others. I also like John Constantine and the old obscure Detective Comics characters Slam Bradley and Pow-Wow Smith.

As for Marvel, of the Avengers I like Thor, Ant-Man, and Captain America. Like the Justifier, I like the Fantastic Four as a group. Individually I like Mister Fantastic (because SCIENCE!). Of the X-Men I like the Professor himself, Cyclops, Banshee, and Jean Grey/Marvel Girl. I also like Doc Strange and the Silver Surfer. Edit: and Machine Man.

Question of the Day #186: What Science Fiction gadget(s) do you think we’ll actually invent?

No, although it doesn’t hurt. I mostly like him because he does the ā€œalien among usā€ thing very well (see also Tempest). And I feel kinda bad for him because he’s usually stuck playing team radio operator for the JLA, so I get really into the rare stories that actually focus on him.

Writers of Hulk comics seem to have one of two problems. Either they write the Hulk as a moronic toddler with super-strength who’s as boring to read as baby food is to eat (see also the Ang Lee Hulk movie), or they do a bunch of weird cloak-and-dagger stuff where military spy-guys are all conspiring to try and figure out where the Hulk is and what he’s doing, and he hardly even shows up on the page (see also the MCU Hulk movie).

Ha! You want ā€œlesser knownā€, I’ll see your Zatanna and raise you a Zauriel…There’s also Major Disaster, although he doesn’t start with A…oh wait, I almost forgot Aztek! And there’s also ā€œFaithā€, but I don’t even know what her deal was supposed to be. Pretty sure ALL of these were invented by Grant Morrison, and what’s neat is that he managed to throw all these new weirdoes of his into the mix while still doing adequate justice to the existing League members. The man’s a bleeding lunatic, but he does good work.

Doctor Fate very specifically weirds me out in the video game ā€œInjustice: Gods Among Usā€, because they gave him a voice like a robot, which seems really odd for a magician. The most memorable JSA members to me are Hawkgirl (and sometimes Hawkman, but he’s more of a cliche when he shows up at all, she’s got more of a character going on), Mister Terrific (weird Batman-esque genius inventor), and of course Power Girl. My single favorite story involving them was a JLA/JSA crossover where seven heroes got possessed by the Deadly Sins from Shazam’s Rock of Eternity. Naturally, PG got Lust…

Saturn Girl and Braniac-5 are the only ones that really stand out to me; the characters are intentionally designed to be very one-note and generic seeming, since the thing they’re doing is basically putting on a uniform and joining a fraternity/sorority/other whatchamacallit. Like I said before, I enjoy ensemble books; X-Men is better than Legion because the characters are more distinctive, but it’s a similar effect either way.

I know Slam Bradley, but I’ve never heard of the other one. I’m guessing he’s a somewhat offensive Native American stereotype by modern standards? No judgment if that’s true and you still like him anyway. I for one got a HUGE kick out of the moment in Grant Morrison’s JLA run where Manitou Raven, the prehistoric shaman who’d been played entirely straight as the team’s magical specialist for months, suddenly said ā€œInuk-chuk!ā€ and turned out to have been the cringeworthy Superfriends cartoon’s ā€œIndian Chiefā€ (actual name of the character, to tell you how much effort they put into him) all along. You can make something brilliant out of something awful, so we should never be afraid to acknowledge our industry’s past, even if it makes us feel uncomfortable now.

Well the Japanese have invented Universal Translators, so I don’t know if I can count that. Overall, it seems clear that our ingenuity is maximized when applied to a subject such as communication or medicine, something that triggers our humanitarian instinct (and is held back when it also triggers our materialistic greed instinct, which is why cel phones are so expensive and why medical insurance is a nightmare, but the first part is why those technologies exist at all). So if it’s technologically feasible to do some sort of faster-than-light communication, we’ll figure that out a lot more easily than we will the process of actually transporting things from planet to planet. And medical technology is a crapshoot in terms of what could happen; we’re already 3D-printing replacement organs, so it’s hard for sci-fi to do much that’s beyond our current stage. The most unrealistic thing about Doctor Crusher or Bashir’s or Phlox’s sickbays is not the fact that they have the ability to fix any disease or injury (unless the plot of the week says otherwise), it’s the fact that the doctor just does it, without anybody getting a bill afterward.

Got cut off, so here’s the last/first part I wanted to respond to.

Supes is the team heavy; Steppenwolf is effectively a Progeny-level threat, so if you imagine that the Superman player couldn’t draw any of the cards he needed to participate usefully in the threat, you’d get a similar effect. He’s on H=5 and you’ve only got 4 heroes, you’re going to have a bad time, but then someone playing a top-tier hero like Grandpa Legacy suddenly gets their Legacy Ring or Final Evolution or whatever else they’ve been missing, and the whole battle swings.

Oh I loved that about him. The lasso scene cracks me up every time.

Agreed, they were trying a little too hard with him, making him the token Millenial with a bunch of awkward humor that didn’t land for me, and going out of his way to mention that he’s Jewish for no real reason. It’d have been way better if they could have gotten Grant Gustin from the TV show Flash to just play his character in the movie, but of course the lawyers say no. (ā€œThe Lawyersā€ needs to be a difficulty 5 villain deck so that all the Sentinels can beat up on them, even though they’ll still lose.)

I didn’t know Green Arrow had ever been in the JLA. Green Lantern’s absence was due to the poor performance of the 2011 movie (which I for one did think was okay, but I get why a lot of people didn’t). They did at least have a cameo showing an alien GL in the historical battle, along with supposedly also having all the gods from the Wonder Woman movie, although I couldn’t recognize any of them except maybe Ares for a split second.

My last comment about JLA is that Cyborg was absolutely perfect, and I’m really sad that his solo movie never happened. I wouldn’t necessarily see him as a replacement for J’onn, but if that was the direction they went, I’m okay with it. As far as ā€œblack representationā€ goes, whatever you think of that topic, having a real black dude as one of the heroes is definitely preferable to having a Martian just choose to appear as a black dude, which is the way at least TWO other franchises I can think of have gone with it.

True, true.

I tip my hat to your superior knowledge of obscurity, my good sir.

Oh yeah, I forgot about the Hawks and Mister Terrific. I suppose I like them too.

True. I think I would be challenged to assign any of them any personality traits.

Gee, I don’t know. I’m fairly bad at judging if portrayals of minority character are offensive or not. I don’t think he is, but then again I could be entirely wrong. His gimmick was trying to solve conflicts peacefully, which I don’t think is a Native American stereotype, but I could be wrong on that too.

Who ever said you don’t learn something new every day?

Yeah, I guess that makes sense.

I’m not saying tough guy Aquaman is a bad character, just that it’s not at all true to his classic comic book rendition.

I 100% agree.

Oh, he definitely was. Ollie joined the League in JLA #4 in '61, a year after the team formed in The Brave & the Bold #28. He was the first non-founding member to join. Sadly, though, I don’t think the Emerald Archer features in many adaptations or reboots of the team, because some audience might think him too similar to the Dark Knight.

Oh, definitely.

QotD #186 Reply: Definitely not anti-gravity, teleportation, or laser-swords, because I’m pretty sure those break some laws of physics. If we ever build a time machine, it’ll probably be something like this. I’ll put my money on some relatively likely options: robits and nanotech.

Question of the Day #187: If you dyed your hair, what colour would you dye it?

Well pretty much everyone seems to regard classic Aquaman as a joke; aside entirely from whether succumbing to that trap would have ruined a movie’s public launch and cost the company millions of dollars, I also think it would have been viewed badly just in terms of the character’s reception among fans. I personally would prefer a version of Aquaman who was about 75% of the way from Super-Friends fish-telepathy version toward Momoaman; the latter is a little too much of an attitudebro for my taste, so I’d dial down his 'tude and the chip on his shoulder, but still make him a fairly Cable-esque hardass kind of a character, because I think that’s what you have to do in order to make him work in the JLA. Batman is the only other character in the league that isn’t a shining idealist, and Aquaman is too low-powered to work as yet another of those; he’s just going to end up in the shadow of Supes and Wondy. But he’s so inherently different from Batman on the surface of things that, even if you make him a little grimdark, he isn’t going to feel redundant with Bats at all.

To me, Aquaman is the character who will die if he’s out of water for 24 hours…and at the 23 hours and 45 minutes mark, he’s going to be in the middle of the desert, stalking a bad guy down to the absolute wire, doing everything he has to do to accomplish his heroic mission, regardless of the cost. He has to have a vulnerability, not the way Supes does because he’s too powerful otherwise, but rather to show him being able to overcome it through sheer force of will.

187 answer: I dunno, a couple of streaks of green perhaps. I think I seriously considered dying my hair when i was in my 20s, but I don’t remember what I had in mind, and I probably wouldn’t want it now.

I think I’d say my ideal Aquaman is neither heavily Superfriends flavor nor badass muscle-dude. The Arthur Curry I prefer is a leader, a real King of the Seven Seas.

I wouldn’t say that. Barry Allen, GL, the Manhunter from Mars, and Green Arrow are Heroes for sure, but none of them strike me as particularly idealistic.

I would argue that Aquaman isn’t very low-powered. He’s certainly at least as powerful as WW. To quote his page on the official DC website . . .

The main problem is that Aquaman just works pretty poorly in a team setting. He’s very powerful under the waves, but above them, not so much.

Absolutely. But he doesn’t have to be this gruff, tattooed, musclebound dude to do that.

Finally, my vision of Aquaman is pretty accurately exemplified by this quote from him from Kingdom Come:

QotD #187 Reply: Probably white or greay [sic].

Question of the Day #188: Do you think the continual advancement of technology will eventually lead to a dystopia or a utopia, or something in betwixt?

The Lantern is literally a shining beacon of order in the darkness of the cosmos, Flash routinely interacts with a not-incredibly-bleak future, thereby proving at least that the world will survive, and while J’onn does have a tragic past that colors his worldview somewhat, he also has a power suite very similar to Superman and thus feels somewhat like that kind of soaring heroic ideal, just not as much so. I’ll give you Arrow, he does have a lesser version of Batman’s shtick going on, but like I’ve said before I tend to forget he was actually in the JLA.

I’m not saying he’s incredibly weak, but when he’s compared to Wondy’s amazing strength, Flash’s amazing speed, Superman’s amazing both of those, and even Batman’s amazing wealth, it’s a bit of a struggle to Justify why he’s in the same tier. It’s like being the fighter in a high level DnD party… sure you can cut a triceratops in half with two chops of your axe, but your party cleric can call down a celestial tacnuke to burn the trike to cinders, the druid can polymorph the trike into a newt, and the wizard can teleport the trike to the Elemental Plane of Flaming Radioactive Acid, so you might feel a little outclassed. And so much of Aquaman as a character is tied up with the sea, which most human beings really don’t care about much. It’d be enough of a struggle to get readers interested in Forestman or Desertman, and people can find environments like that just by walking or driving… the sea is even more remote, and to most people it’s just this empty inhospitable place where they can’t go and they wouldn’t find anything if they did. Writers trying to make the ocean interesting, so that we’ll care about the guy who lives there, are just starting at a disadvantage compared to a hero who operates in cities which are full of ordinary, recognizable people.

Exactly. It’d be hard to make people care about SiberiaMan, or MoonMan who lives on the Moon and protects a city full of moon people who aren’t very person-like by our standards. The JLA are the greatest heroes in the world, and he’s definitely on the same level as them, but it’s like being in a League of Kings, where you’ve got the kings of England and Russia and Germany and Spain, and Aquaman is like the king of Serbia or Latvia or something… he’s just not going to feel quite as regal as his peers.

The tattoos are weird, I’ll give you that. But he absolutely should be muscular, if somewhat streamlined. The long hair is kinda impractical, but you could say the same about Wonder Woman.

That is a very good quote, for sure.

The technology itself has the potential to solve all of our problems, but the research to create the technology is funded at the sufferance of the world’s multi-billionaire corporations, and their selfish short-sightedness will probably doom us to dystopia long before they invent the devices which make utopia possible. It is the fundamental nature of human behavior which must change first, and then technology can take us the rest of the way. Right now all our amazing technology can manage to do is indulge the laziness and cowardice of the many; our willingness to sacrifice ourselves for the sake of some better is what we need to advance in, not just our skill in gadget building. Or we could just make some AI ā€œchildrenā€ and then remove our deeply flawed selves from the equation, in the hopes that the robots can do personhood better than a bunch of upjumped monkeys can manage it.

Yeah, definitely dystopia. The minority people in power are predominantly too greedy / self-centered to be willing to make the ā€œsacrificesā€ to help the majority of people without. :unamused:

(Sorry – in a mood right now… :roll_eyes:)

We’ve gone several days without a QOTD…

Yeah, sorry about neglecting my Duty as Questioneer like that. I’ve been fairly busy lately.

I’ve always felt that it was a pretty raw deal that the Flash gets one power, and then Supes also has that power. No other JLAer is completely overshadowed by the Big Blue Boy Scout like that.

He’s the King of Atlantis and the Seven Seas. I’m pretty sure all the lost treasures of the world’s oceans plus the wealth of an entire highly advanced Magi-Tech nation outweighs that of a billionaire CEO. Admittedly, Aquaman doesn’t really use that wealth for much . . .

Yeah, this right here is the real root of the problem.

Yeah, but he should also wear a shirt.

QotD #188 Reply: I don’t think technology needs to get any more advanced for us to have a dystopia. I suppose the same is somewhat true for a utopia, but like others have said, it’s mostly about who controls the technology.

Question of the Day #189: If your house got destroyed in a tragic gerbil stampede, would you rather live in a large 19th-Century Galleon or a large 20th-Century Zeppelin?

Don’t stress it! :slight_smile: Life is far more important. :wink:

19th-Century Galleon. No fuel needs and maintainable. (My grandparents had boats, so I love being out on the water.)

Also, if I fall off, I can get back on without too much of a problem… :wink: